Skip to content

Mapping Medieval West African States

A discussion of how to teach the different borders of the medieval West African empires (Ghana/Wagadu, Mali, Songhay)

Bram Hubbell
Bram Hubbell
4 min read
Mapping Medieval West African States
From Robert Harms' Africa in Global History with Sources

As I’ve been reading about the empires of Ghana, Mali, and Songhay, I’ve noticed a lot of differences in the maps of these empires. Each textbook and monograph seems to have surprisingly different borders for these states. I was thinking about how students might react to these differences. Most of our students have grown up in a world where political borders matter and states rigorously patrol their borders. They most likely don’t inuitively understand that borders used to be more fluid and permeable.

I found this helpful quote from Robert Harms in Africa in Global History with Sources:

Ghana, Mali, and Songhay were medieval empires that differed in significant ways from the modern states that populate the world today. Whereas border control is a hallmark of the modern state, the boundaries of medieval empires were only vaguely defined, and they expanded and contracted with the waxing and waning of power at the center. The kings sought to control their vassals through webs of personal relationships and economic ties rather than through legal or constitutional frameworks. Relationships with their vassals, allies, and enemies defined the empires more accurately than did notions of territorial integrity. In the sparsely populated Sahel, control of trading towns and agriculturally rich floodplains was far more important than dominion over vast expanses of semiarid land.

Using this quote and an assortment of maps, we can help students understand how premodern states differ from modern states. Premodern states rarely controlled territory or people in the way that modern states can. Rulers often relied on many informal means for maintaining order in locations far from the capital of the state. This approach means that the borders we see on these maps do not best represent the government’s actual degree of control over the territory.


Related Posts

Members Public

Summer Break and Summer Special

After spending most of my life either attending or teaching school in the Northeast of the United States, the school calendar is my default calendar. New years begin on Labor Day, and summer is time for an extended break. I started publishing Liberating Narratives as a newsletter just after Labor

Summer Break and Summer Special
Members Public

“Famous Fabric Stores”: Song Chinese Silk

Discussion of teaching silk production in Song China

“Famous Fabric Stores”: Song Chinese Silk
Members Public

The Popularity of East Asian Buddhist Woodblock Prints

Discussion of using images to teach continuity of Buddhism in East Asia

The Popularity of East Asian Buddhist Woodblock Prints